As artificial intelligence expands, so does the infrastructure needed to support it. Across Wisconsin, several large data center projects are raising questions about their effects on the environment, public health and nearby communities.

Amy Barrilleaux, host of Clean Wisconsin’s “The Defender” podcast, discussed those concerns on October 19, during a virtual session of the Sustainability Speaker Series. The series is a partnership of the River Falls Public Library, the University of Wisconsin-River Falls Office of Sustainability and Hope for Earth. Clean Wisconsin is an environmental advocacy group dedicated to protecting Wisconsin’s natural resources.

Barrilleaux outlined three major environmental concerns about AI data centers: energy use, water use and land development.

“These are magnitudes larger than those old data centers that we might have talked about in the past,” Barrilleaux said, explaining why newer AI facilities need far more resources than traditional data centers.

Three major AI data center projects are under construction or operating in Wisconsin: Microsoft’s campus in Mount Pleasant, the Vantage Data Centers campus in Port Washington, which is being built for Oracle and OpenAI, and Meta’s campus in Beaver Dam.

According to a Clean Wisconsin analysis, the three projects could increase Wisconsin’s peak electricity demand by about 4.17 gigawatts by 2032. Barrilleaux said 1 gigawatt of AI center demand equals the electricity demand of about 1.1 million Wisconsin homes.

That means the three projects could need enough electricity to power about 4.6 million homes. Wisconsin has about 2.8 million housing units.

The growing demand also raises questions about how that electricity will be generated.

Barrilleaux said seven new natural gas power plants have been approved or proposed in Wisconsin in the past two years. In addition, three coal plants, Alliant’s Edgewater and Colombia plants and We Energies Oak Creek plant, that were expected to close have had their retirement dates pushed back.

The expansion of fossil fuel power raises concerns about both climate change and public health. Natural gas power plants release pollutants including nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide and fine particulate matter. Barrilleaux said these pollutants can worsen air quality and are linked to respiratory and cardiovascular problems.

AI data centers also rely on diesel generators for backup power. Barrilleaux raised concerns about the pollution from these generators, even when they are used mainly as backups.

A Clean Wisconsin analysis of the Vantage campus found that its backup diesel generators could cause up to $1.3 million a year in statewide public health costs, mostly from increased ozone pollution.

Water use is another concern.

Some companies promote closed-loop cooling systems as a way to cut water use. Barrilleaux said questions remain about the chemicals used in those systems and how they are disposed of.

She also said that counting only the water a data center uses directly does not give a complete picture of its environmental impact.

Much of the water tied to data centers is used indirectly, through electricity generation. Barrilleaux said about 70% of Wisconsin’s water withdrawals go to power generation.

According to Clean Wisconsin’s analysis, if the electricity for the three projects came from natural gas, power plants could need up to 74 million gallons of water a day.

Beyond energy and water, Barrilleaux discussed the permanent loss of farmland to data center construction.

AI data center buildings are on average 100,000 square feet. When they are built on farmland, that land is permanently taken out of agricultural use.

Barrilleaux contrasted this with wind and solar projects, where farming can continue around the equipment. She also noted that wind and solar projects must have decommissioning plans approved by the Wisconsin Public Service Commission. Similar requirements do not apply to the data center projects she discussed.

Barrilleaux said communities still have options when facing proposed developments.

She encouraged residents to demand transparency from technology companies and local officials, especially about projected electricity use, water use and backup power systems.

“We need to know how much power a data center will need and how those power needs are going to be met,” Barrilleaux said.

She also encouraged residents to take part in public comment periods when new power plants are proposed before the Public Service Commission.

As Wisconsin continues to attract large technology projects, Barrilleaux said it is important to understand their consequences before they move forward.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *