The River Falls City Council voted unanimously Oct. 27 to end the city’s contract with Flock Safety, the company behind the automated license plate reader cameras installed around the city.

Alderperson Sean Downing spoke about his opinions on the termination of Flock Safety’s contract at the city council meeting. 

“Removing Flock Cameras and any surveillance technology like that is the right action to take. I am grateful for our police chief recognizing Flock’s flaws with transparency. Clearly they are hiding more. I urge the council and the city to reject this invasive mass-surveillance technology and other forms of it. At a large scale it enables warrantless tracking and creates a surveillance spy network that in my opinion violates our Fourth Amendment rights and infringes on our First Amendment rights. Artificial intelligence stitches this data together to expose our private lives, tracking medical visits, religious services, your personal choices you make for you. All of which is supposed to be constitutionally protected, and if not properly protected, information, those generated digital fingerprints and records can be used against people by their own government in ways they have not imagined. There are other basic problems as well, these types of spy networks can be abused. You may have already heard some of the stalking stories. System errors have already led to innocent families being held at gunpoint. Please protect our civil rights and liberties and remove Flock and oppose any other dystopian surveillance technology like it,” Downing said.

The vote came two weeks after the River Falls Police Department announced it would stop using the cameras. After an internal review, the department said it had “lost confidence in Flock Safety as a service provider.” Police turned off data sharing Oct. 9 and covered all nine cameras Oct. 16.

Flock cameras are automated license plate readers that are intended to be used by law enforcement to identify vehicles believed to be connected to crimes.

The cameras have been covered but not removed. City staff asked that the coverings stay in place until the equipment is taken down. No removal date has been announced.

At recent council meetings, residents raised concerns about data sharing, privacy and Flock Safety’s company policies. They also asked the police department to be more open about how the cameras work and how they are used, and urged the council to review the contract.

The city signed a $111,350 contract with Flock Safety on Dec. 5, 2024, to install cameras throughout River Falls. River Falls city council didn’t vote on the initial contract.

According to a frequently asked questions sheet released by the city, the cameras were meant to help police with criminal investigations and improve public safety.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *